Skip to content

Email Marketing Best Practices Part 2: Building and Managing Your Email List

A successful email marketing campaign starts with a high-quality email list. This part of the three-part guide (Part 1 - Technical Setup) focuses on best practices for building your list, the importance of permission-based marketing, and strategies for engaging with a cold list.

Best Practices for Collecting Email Addresses

  1. Offer Value: Provide a compelling reason for people to subscribe, such as exclusive content, discounts, or early access to products.
  2. Use Multiple Touchpoints: Collect emails through various channels:
    • Website sign-up forms
    • Social media platforms
    • In-store at point of sale
    • Events and trade shows
    • Webinars or online courses
  3. Optimize Your Sign-Up Forms:
    • Keep forms simple, asking only for essential information
    • Use clear and compelling call-to-action (CTA) buttons
    • Place forms strategically on your website (e.g., header, footer, pop-ups)
  4. Implement Double Opt-In: Use a two-step process where subscribers confirm their email address. This ensures higher quality leads and helps maintain list hygiene.
  5. Be Transparent: Clearly communicate what subscribers can expect in terms of content and frequency.

The Importance of Permission-Based Marketing

Permission-based marketing is not just ethical; it's also more effective and often required by law:

  1. Legal Compliance: Adheres to regulations like GDPR, CAN-SPAM, and CASL.
  2. Higher Engagement: Subscribers who actively choose to receive your emails are more likely to engage with your content.
  3. Better Deliverability: ISPs favor senders with high engagement rates, improving your overall deliverability.
  4. Brand Trust: Respecting user preferences builds trust and enhances your brand reputation.
  5. Reduced Spam Complaints: Explicit permission significantly lowers the risk of spam complaints.

To maintain a permission-based list:

  • Always use opt-in methods (preferably double opt-in)
  • Provide clear unsubscribe options in every email
  • Regularly clean your list by removing inactive subscribers

Strategies for Slowly Warming Up a Cold List

If you have a list of contacts who haven't engaged with your emails in a while (a "cold" list), it's crucial to approach re-engagement carefully:

  1. Segment Your List: Divide your cold list based on factors like last engagement date, purchase history, or original sign-up source.
  2. Start with a Re-permission Campaign:
    • Send a campaign asking subscribers if they still want to hear from you
    • Be clear about the value you'll provide and the email frequency
    • Remove those who don't respond or opt out
  3. Gradual Increase in Volume: Start by sending to a small portion of your list and gradually increase the volume over time.
  4. Monitor Engagement Metrics: Keep a close eye on open rates, click-through rates, and spam complaints. Adjust your strategy based on these metrics.
  5. Provide High-Value Content: Ensure your re-engagement emails offer significant value to incentivize opens and clicks.
  6. Use a Winback Series: Create a series of emails designed to re-engage subscribers, each with a unique angle or offer.
  7. Update Your Content and Design: Refresh your email templates and content strategy to appeal to your audience's current needs and preferences.
  8. Consider Timing and Frequency: Experiment with different send times and adjust your email frequency based on engagement data.
  9. Implement Sunset Policies: After multiple attempts at re-engagement, have a policy to remove persistently unengaged subscribers from your list.

Remember, it's better to have a smaller, engaged list than a large, unresponsive one. Focus on quality over quantity, and always prioritize the preferences and experiences of your subscribers.

By following these practices for building and managing your email list, you'll create a solid foundation for your email marketing efforts. A high-quality, engaged list is key to achieving strong open rates, click-through rates, and ultimately, conversions from your email campaigns.

Email Marketing Best Practices Complete Guide

Email Marketing Best Practices Part 1: Technical Setup

Read More

Email Marketing Best Practices Part 2: Building and Managing Your Email List

Read More

Email Marketing Best Practices Part 3: Content Creation and Strategy

Read More

Email Marketing Best Practices Part 4: Nurture Campaigns and Lifecycle Marketing

Read More

Email Marketing Best Practices Part 5: Lead Magnets and List Growth

Read More

Email Marketing Best Practices Part 6: Email Automation and Workflows 

Read More

Email Marketing Best Practices Part 7: Metrics and Analytics

Read More

Email Marketing Best Practices Part 8: Compliance and Best Practices

Read More

Need help with your email setup? Connect with us today for a free consultation.